Insights · Welding

Straight Seam Welder vs Circumferential Seam Welder: Which One Your Shop Needs

What a straight (longitudinal) seam welder and a circumferential (girth) seam welder each do, which jobs need which, when a shop needs both, and what to check on fit-up, process, thickness and length before you order.

Who this guide is for

This guide is for owners and production managers of duct, tank, cylinder, fan housing and steel fabrication shops who are deciding which seam welder to buy, or whether to buy both. It explains what each machine does, which jobs need which, and what we need from you to quote the right one.

What each machine does

A rolled shell has two kinds of seam, and they run in different directions.

  • Straight (longitudinal) seam. The seam where the two edges of the rolled plate meet, running along the length of the cylinder. Our straight seam welders do this. The vertical machine stands the duct section upright and runs the torch down the seam.
  • Circumferential (girth) seam. The round seam that joins one shell to another, or a flange, head or end cap to a shell. Our circumferential seam and flange welders do this. The work turns under a fixed torch, so every point of the seam sees the same speed and torch angle.

The usual order is: roll the blank into a cylinder on a four-roll plate rolling machine, weld the straight seam, then join sections or fit flanges and caps by circumferential welding. The two machines are two steps in one sequence, so the question is how much of that sequence your jobs contain.

Which jobs need which

Match the seams on your drawings to the machines.

  • Round duct, single section. One longitudinal seam per section, so a straight seam welder covers it. The vertical machine on our pages also switches to square duct at the touch screen, without changing the clamping fixture or the copper backing bar.
  • Large or flanged duct. Longitudinal seams on every section, then circumferential seams where sections join and where flanges go on. You need both. The large round duct flange and seam welder turns sections on roller beds for flange and duct-to-duct joints.
  • Tanks and pressure-free vessels. Shell seams are longitudinal, and heads, bottoms and flanged rings are circumferential. You need both. If a vessel falls under a pressure vessel code, the welding procedure and welder qualification set the rules, not the machine, so check your code before you choose.
  • Fan housings and casings. A rolled casing needs its longitudinal seam, and side plates or flanges go on with circumferential welds. In most cases both.
  • Chimney, flue and exhaust stacks. Each straight section needs the longitudinal seam. Joined lengths and flanges need circumferential welding. Stainless stacks usually call for the cleaner TIG finish.

One test settles most cases: count the seams on one finished part. If every seam runs along the length, you need a straight seam welder. If there are round seams as well, you need circumferential welding too. Under internal pressure the longitudinal seam of a cylinder carries about twice the stress of the girth seam, which is why it often gets the closer inspection in vessel work.

When you need both

Buy both when your parts are longer than one rolled shell, when you fit flanges, heads or end caps, or when you build large ducts, tanks and casings from several sections. Buy only a straight seam welder when you make single-section cylinders or duct and the ends are finished some other way. Buy only a circumferential welder when you receive rolled or pipe shells and your work is joining, flanging and capping them. If you are unsure, tell us the parts you make and we suggest which to start with. The two can be bought in stages, starting with the one that clears your biggest bottleneck.

Diameter, thickness and length from the spec tables

These are the catalogue figures on our product pages. Final figures depend on your parts and material and are confirmed on the quotation.

MachineDiameterThicknessLengthProcess
Straight seam, vertical, round duct250 to 1600 mm1.0 to 3.0 mmWeld length 1500 mmTIG or MIG/MAG
Straight seam, vertical, square ductFrom 220 x 220 mm0.8 to 2.5 mmWeld length 1500 mmTIG or MIG/MAG
Straight seam, laser tracking, small cylinders100 to 400 mm0.8 to 1.5 mm150 to 1500 mmLaser seam tracking, no jig
Circumferential, vertical ring-seam, stainlessD 720 to 1700 mm0.8 to 4 mmL 650 to 1250 mmTIG with filler wire
Circumferential, large round duct flange and seam welder300 to 2000 mm (3500 mm at the limit)1.0 to 10 mmSections 1200 to 4500 mmConfirmed on quotation
Circumferential, double-torchConfirmed on quotationConfirmed on quotationConfirmed on quotationTwo independent torches, wire feeder can be added

Read the thickness column against your real work. The vertical straight seam welder is listed to 3.0 mm for round duct, while our four-roll machine rolls carbon steel up to 6 mm and stainless up to 3 mm. If your shells are thicker than the straight seam welder is listed for, say so before you order, and we confirm each station on the quotation. On the circumferential side, the large-duct welder lists 2.5 to 10 mm carbon steel at diameters 1500 to 3500 mm, and 2 to 10 mm stainless at those diameters. Length is the other limit: the vertical machine lists a weld length of 1500 mm, so a longer shell is built from several rolled courses joined by girth seams.

Fit-up and clamping

A machine welds the joint you give it. Whichever one you buy, the edges must be square, clean and closed evenly.

  • Straight seam. The vertical machine holds the seam with a clamping fixture and a copper backing bar. A copper bar behind a thin sheet or stainless seam supports the root and draws heat away from the joint, which helps limit distortion. It needs to stay clean and in firm contact with the sheet.
  • Circumferential seam. The ring-seam welder is listed with tack welds about 3 mm long every 50 mm and a joint gap of 0.5 to 1 mm. It holds cylinders and cones upright on a turntable and reaches inner, outer and corner seams in one clamping. The large-duct welder turns sections on roller beds.
  • Roundness. A shell that is out of round leaves a gap no torch closes well. Our hydraulic four-roll machine lists a remaining flat after pre-bending of up to 1.5 x plate thickness (1.0 x for the full-servo model), and a shorter flat gives a rounder cylinder.

Welding process

Our pages list TIG and MIG/MAG. TIG gives the cleaner weld on stainless and thin sheet and is slower. MIG/MAG is faster and suits carbon steel and thicker material. Our guide to welding methods in HVAC duct fabrication compares them in more detail. The vertical straight seam welder is listed with TIG or MIG/MAG at 3 to 8 mm/s, the ring-seam welder uses TIG with filler wire, and internal and external gas shielding can be added for a cleaner stainless weld. If your job needs a process that is not on our pages, tell us and we check.

Galvanized sheet can be welded, but the zinc burns off, so plan fume extraction and a clean-up of the weld area, and confirm that your customer accepts a welded galvanized seam.

Buying checklist

  • Count the seams on one finished part, longitudinal and circumferential, and note which are inside, outside or at a corner.
  • List the smallest and largest diameter and the longest section.
  • Check thickness against the welder, not only against the rolling machine.
  • Decide the weld finish and the process with us before you order.
  • Agree how fit-up is done, who tacks, and what gap your edges leave.
  • Check floor space and power: the vertical straight seam welder is 1900 x 1930 x 2810 mm at 15 kW, the large-duct welder is 6900 x 4300 x 3400 mm at 48 kW, and the double-torch welder is listed at 20 kW maximum on 380 V.
  • Plan fume extraction and a crane or hoist route for long or heavy sections.

What we need from you to quote

  • Material and grade, and thickness range
  • Smallest and largest diameter, and the section or seam length
  • Seam types: longitudinal, girth, flange to duct, cone, end cap
  • Welding process and weld finish you need
  • Parts per shift, site power supply and destination port

Send your parts and seam types for a quote in 12 hours →

Taokron supplies these machines. Taokron (Melbourne) handles inquiry, specification review, quotation, pre-shipment inspection, shipping and after-sales support. Catalogue figures are confirmed on the quotation for your parts. If you are also planning the rolling station, see our round duct rolling and welding line buyer guide.

FAQ

What is the difference between a straight seam welder and a circumferential seam welder?

A straight seam welder closes the longitudinal seam along the length of a rolled shell. A circumferential seam welder welds the round seams: cylinder to cylinder, flange to duct and end cap to duct, with the work turning under a fixed torch.

Do I need both machines?

If you only roll and weld single-section cylinders or duct, a straight seam welder may be enough. If you join sections end to end, or fit flanges, heads or end caps, you also need circumferential welding. Many tank, fan housing and large duct shops run both.

What thickness can each machine weld?

On our pages the vertical straight seam welder is listed at 1.0 to 3.0 mm for round duct and 0.8 to 2.5 mm for square duct. The vertical ring-seam welder is listed at 0.8 to 4 mm stainless steel, and the large round duct flange and seam welder at 1.0 to 10 mm. If your seams are thicker than the figure listed for the machine you need, tell us and we confirm on the quotation.

Which welding process do these machines use?

The straight seam welder is listed with TIG or MIG/MAG. The ring-seam welder uses TIG with filler wire, and the double-torch circumferential welder can take a wire feeder. If you need a process that is not on our pages, say so and we check.

How must the parts be prepared before welding?

Edges should be square and clean and the joint closed evenly. The ring-seam welder is listed with tack welds about 3 mm long every 50 mm and a joint gap of 0.5 to 1 mm. The vertical straight seam welder holds the seam with clamping and a copper backing bar. Send drawings and we confirm the fit-up for each machine.

What do I send you to get a quotation?

Material and grade, thickness range, smallest and largest diameter, seam length or section length, the seam types you weld, the welding process and weld finish you need, parts per shift, and your site power supply and destination port.

Duct Shop Notes

One email a month for duct shop owners

Notes on machine choices, shop layout, duct standards and new machines. Reply "unsubscribe" any time to stop.

12-hour reply

Send your parts, material and thickness range. Ryan Tao replies within 12 hours with a configuration, lead time and price.

Ask an engineer

Engineer reply

Ask an engineer about this guide

Describe your job and what you are trying to make. Ryan Tao replies within 12 hours.

Guide: Straight Seam Welder vs Circumferential Seam Welder: Which One Your Shop Needs